In this guide
- What Is Cross-Examination in a Family Law Hearing?
- When Does the Family Violence Cross-Examination Ban Apply?
- The Commonwealth Family Violence Cross-Examination Scheme
- How the Ban Works in Parenting Matters
- Domestic Violence Order Hearings in Queensland: A Separate Set of Rules
- What Happens on Hearing Day When the Ban Applies
- If the Court Decides the Ban Does Not Apply
- How to Prepare Before Your Hearing
- Common Myths About the Ban
- Family Violence vs Domestic Violence: Why the Difference Matters
- Why Legal Representation Matters
If you are preparing for a family law hearing against a former partner who has been violent or controlling, one question usually comes first: will they be allowed to question me directly? In most cases involving family violence, the answer is no.
Under the family violence cross-examination ban in the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), a party cannot personally cross-examine the other party when certain conditions are met. Instead, a lawyer asks the questions.
At Collective Family Law, we regularly prepare clients for hearings where the ban applies.
This guide explains when it applies, how it differs from the rules in Queensland domestic violence order hearings, what happens on the day and how to prepare.
The ban at a glance
- What it is: a rule in section 102NA of the Family Law Act 1975 that stops parties from personally cross-examining each other in certain family violence cases.
- When it applies: automatically where there is a violence-related charge or conviction between the parties, a final family violence order that applies to both of them, or a personal protection injunction. The court can also order the ban in other cases where family violence is alleged.
- Which matters: parenting and property matters alike.
- Who asks the questions: a lawyer, either one you engage privately or one provided through the Commonwealth cross-examination scheme.
- Do you still give evidence? Yes. The difference is that a lawyer questions you, not your former partner.
What Is Cross-Examination in a Family Law Hearing?
Cross-examination takes place at a final hearing, when one party asks the other party and their witnesses questions to test their evidence.
When a party has a lawyer, the lawyer conducts it. A self-represented party, however, would ordinarily ask the questions personally.
Before the reforms, this meant a self-represented person could question a former partner directly, even where there had been serious abuse.
For many people, that turned the courtroom into another place where intimidation could continue. The ban has applied to cross-examination since 10 September 2019, both to protect people who have experienced family violence and to help the court hear evidence that is not shaped by fear.
When Does the Family Violence Cross-Examination Ban Apply?
The ban applies in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, which hears family law matters for the Gold Coast.
There must first be an allegation of family violence between the parties. From there, the ban either applies automatically or by court order.
Situation | Does the ban apply? |
|---|---|
Either party has been charged with or convicted of an offence involving violence, or a threat of violence, against the other | Yes, automatically |
A final family violence order applies to both parties | Yes, automatically |
The court has made an injunction for the personal protection of either party | Yes, automatically |
Family violence is alleged, but none of the above applies | Not automatically, although the court can order it |
Family violence is not alleged | No |
An interim family violence order does not trigger the ban on its own. If that is your situation, you or your lawyer can still ask the court to apply it.
Importantly, the ban works in both directions. It protects the person who alleges violence, and it equally prevents that person from questioning the other party. Neither party cross-examines the other personally.
The Commonwealth Family Violence Cross-Examination Scheme
The Commonwealth Family Violence and Cross-examination of Parties Scheme provides a lawyer for the cross-examination stage where the ban applies. In Queensland, it is administered by Legal Aid Queensland.
Unlike an ordinary grant of legal aid, the scheme is not limited by a means test or a merit test. You may, however, be asked to contribute to the cost of the representation.
A scheme lawyer generally acts only for the cross-examination, not for the rest of your matter. They will also need clear instructions from you about which parts of the other party’s evidence to test. For that reason, where a matter is complex, many clients choose to engage a lawyer for the whole case rather than relying on the scheme alone.
How the Ban Works in Parenting Matters
The ban applies to property matters, but it often matters most in parenting matters (sometimes called custody cases). Parenting disputes turn on safety, routine and each parent’s role, and evidence about family violence can significantly influence the outcome.
When the ban applies, a parent who has experienced violence does not have to answer questions about the children from the person who harmed them. Moreover, because the court treats the safety of children and parents as a primary consideration, a lawyer can keep the questioning focused on what the judge needs to decide: what happened, what risk it poses to the children and which arrangements would be safe.
Domestic Violence Order Hearings in Queensland: A Separate Set of Rules
Many people are confused by the fact that two different sets of rules can apply, in two different courts.
The family law ban described above applies in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, where parenting and property matters are decided. By contrast, applications for a domestic violence order in Queensland are heard in the Magistrates Court under the Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012 (Qld). Under section 150 of that Act, a respondent cannot personally cross-examine a protected witness, who is usually the person the order protects. Instead, the respondent needs a lawyer to ask the questions.
The two systems are also connected. A final domestic violence order between the parties automatically triggers the family law ban. As a result, the outcome of a protection order hearing can change how a later parenting or property hearing runs.
What Happens on Hearing Day When the Ban Applies
For many clients, not knowing what to expect is the hardest part. A hearing where the ban applies usually runs as follows.
- Before the hearing: the court identifies that the ban applies. If you do not have a lawyer, you can apply to Legal Aid Queensland under the scheme.
- Instructions: you tell your lawyer which parts of the other party’s evidence you want tested.
- Your evidence: you give evidence. The other party’s lawyer, if they have one, can still cross-examine you, because the ban stops the other party personally rather than their lawyer.
- Their evidence: your lawyer cross-examines the other party and their witnesses on your instructions.
- Afterwards: a scheme lawyer’s role usually ends once cross-examination is complete. You then continue the matter yourself or with your own lawyer.
If the Court Decides the Ban Does Not Apply
The ban is not the only protection available. Where family violence is alleged but the ban does not apply, the court must still ensure that appropriate protections are in place for the person being cross-examined. For example, the court may direct that personal cross-examination take place by video or audio link, so the parties are not in the same room.
Courts can also offer separate waiting rooms, staggered arrival and departure times and screens in the courtroom. If you have safety concerns, raise them with the court registry as early as possible. Our team helps clients make these requests well before the hearing date.
How to Prepare Before Your Hearing
Your situation | Best next step |
|---|---|
A final family violence order applies to you both | Expect the ban to apply, and get legal advice early |
You have an interim order, or you allege violence without an order | Tell the court and your lawyer, so they can consider asking for the ban |
You do not have a lawyer | Apply to Legal Aid Queensland under the scheme as soon as the ban applies |
You are the party accused of violence | Arrange your own lawyer so the other party’s evidence can be tested |
Whatever your situation, it helps to:
- prepare a short timeline of the key events and the facts you want tested
- gather relevant documents, such as orders, messages and medical or police records
- ask the registry about safety arrangements for the hearing day.
Common Myths About the Ban
Myth | Fact |
|---|---|
“The ban means I can’t put my side of the story.” | You still give evidence, and a lawyer asks the questions you want asked. |
“I need a domestic violence order first.” | No. A charge or conviction, an injunction or a court order can also trigger it. |
“It only protects the victim.” | It applies equally to both parties, including the person accused. |
“Legal Aid will only help if I can’t afford a lawyer.” | The scheme has no means or merit test, although a contribution may be requested. |
“Nobody will cross-examine me.” | The other party’s lawyer can still cross-examine you. |
Family Violence vs Domestic Violence: Why the Difference Matters
In everyday conversation, most people use the two terms interchangeably. In court, however, the distinction determines which law applies and which court hears the matter.
Family violence | Domestic violence | |
|---|---|---|
Law | Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) | Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012 (Qld) |
Court | Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia | Magistrates Court |
Purpose | Parenting and property orders | Protection orders |
Link to the ban | An allegation allows the court to order the ban | A final order applying to both parties triggers it automatically |
Notably, the family law courts do not need a domestic violence order before they consider family violence. Allegations and findings can still affect parenting outcomes on their own.
Why Legal Representation Matters
Cross-examination is a skill. It requires knowledge of the rules of evidence, a clear sense of what is relevant to the judge, and the ability to test credibility without hostility. In addition, the court has the power to disallow improper questions, and a prepared lawyer keeps the questioning within those limits. For that reason, legal representation helps your evidence come across clearly and reduces the risk of procedural mistakes, particularly where findings about family violence may shape parenting arrangements.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a section 102NA order?
Section 102NA of the Family Law Act 1975 sets out when a party cannot personally cross-examine another party in a family violence case. A section 102NA order is the court’s direction that the ban applies to a particular hearing.
Who pays for the lawyer under the scheme?
The Commonwealth funds the scheme, and Legal Aid Queensland administers it in Queensland. You may be asked to make a contribution.
Can I be cross-examined if the ban applies?
Yes, but only by the other party’s lawyer, not by the other party personally.
What happens if someone makes false allegations of family violence?
The court may give that party’s evidence less weight and can make costs orders. Knowingly giving false evidence can also amount to perjury, which is a criminal offence.
Can I refuse to be a witness in a family law hearing?
Generally, no. If you are served with a subpoena, you must attend and give evidence, although you may be able to object to particular questions, for example on the grounds of privilege.
How common is family and domestic violence in Australia?
According to the ABS Personal Safety Survey (2021–22), reported by the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, about 1 in 6 women and 1 in 18 men have experienced physical or sexual violence from a current or former cohabiting partner since the age of 15.
Talk to Us Before Your Hearing
If a family violence order is in place, or you have concerns about your safety at court, raise them early rather than on the hearing day. That way, the court and your lawyer have time to put the ban and any other protections in place. Collective Family Law can explain how the ban applies to your matter in a confidential conversation. Call 1300 225 393 or book a free consultation.
This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. For advice about your circumstances, please speak with a family lawyer.




